(Worldpress doesn’t much care for my picture as my avatar, it keeps going back to my old one. Perhaps they had too many complaints.
)
The more we learn about the animals, and plants, we share our world with the more we find we are not as unique as we think. We can see creative thinking in other animals, just watch squirrels working out how to get at the bird feeder. Now we have evidence that plants recognize their siblings. “We are family” applies to the plant kingdom as well as our own.
First, in our Bible study I asked you to pick you favorite animal. Now I’ll ask you to make some choices from the world of plants.
Your back on the ark and must choose three flowers to brighten your voyage.
My picks
1. Lily of the Valley – my mother’s favorite flower, her nick name was Lil.

2. Roses - The 2009 award winning Pink Promise.
3. Tulips – The Sensual Touch Tulip.
What three veggies would you pick for the dinner table?
My picks are easy since there aren’t many veggies I do like.
1. Corn
2. Potatoes
3.Carrots
Which three veggies would you throw overboard?
1. Brussels Sprouts
2. Broccoli
3. Lima beans
The article:
http://www.udel.edu/udaily/2010/oct/plantsiblings101409.html
Plants may not have eyes and ears, but they can recognize their siblings, and researchers at the University of Delaware have discovered how.
The ID system lies in the roots and the chemical cues they secrete.
The finding not only sheds light on the intriguing sensing system in plants, but also may have implications for agriculture and even home gardening.
The study, which is reported in the scientific journal Communicative & Integrative Biology, was led by Harsh Bais, assistant professor of plant and soil sciences at the University of Delaware.
Canadian researchers published in 2007 that sea rocket, a common seashore plant, can recognize its siblings — plants grown from seeds from the same mother.
Susan Dudley, an evolutionary plant ecologist at McMaster University in Hamilton, Ontario, and her colleagues observed that when siblings are grown next to each other in the soil, they “play nice” and don’t send out more roots to compete with one another.
However, the moment one of the plants is thrown in with strangers, it begins competing with them by rapidly growing more roots to take up the water and mineral nutrients in the soil.
Bais, who has conducted a variety of research on plant signaling systems, read Dudley’s study and wanted to find the mechanism behind the sibling recognition.
“Plants have no visible sensory markers, and they can’t run away from where they are planted,” Bais says. “It then becomes a search for more complex patterns of recognition.”
Working in his laboratory at the Delaware Biotechnology Institute, a major center for life sciences research at UD, Bais and doctoral student Meredith Biedrzycki set up a study with wild populations of Arabidopsis thaliana.
They utilized wild populations to avoid issues with this common laboratory-bred species, which “always has cousins floating around in the lab,” Bais says.
In a series of experiments, young seedlings were exposed to liquid media containing the root secretions or “exudates” from siblings, from strangers (non-siblings), or only their own exudates.
The length of the longest lateral root and of the hypocotyl, the first leaf-like structure that forms on the plant, were measured.
Additionally, in one experiment, the root exudates were inhibited by sodium orthovanadate, which specifically blocks root secretions without imparting adverse growth effects on roots.
The exposure of plants to the root exudates of strangers induced greater lateral root formation than exposure of plants to sibling exudates. Stranger recognition was abolished upon treatment with the secretion inhibitor.
Biedrzycki did the painstaking laboratory research, rotating more than 3,000 plants involved in the study every day for seven consecutive days and documenting the root patterns.
“The research was very painstaking because Arabidopsis roots are nearly translucent when they are young and were also tangled when I removed them from plates, so measuring the roots took a great amount of patience,” Biedrzycki notes.
“This manuscript is very important for my research since the focus of my thesis project is understanding the biochemical mechanism behind root secretions,” she says. “This research has allowed me to probe the natural mechanism of kin recognition and root secretion.”
The study was replicated by Dudley’s lab in Canada, with similar results.
Strangers planted next to each other are often shorter, Bais notes, because so much of their energy is directed at root growth.
Because siblings aren’t competing against each other, their roots are often much shallower.
Bais says he and his colleagues also have noticed that as sibling plants grow next to each other, their leaves often will touch and intertwine compared to strangers that grow rigidly upright and avoid touching.
The study leaves a lot of unanswered questions that Bais hopes to explore further. How might sibling plants grown in large “monocultures,” such as corn or other major crop plants, be affected? Are they more susceptible to pathogens? And how do they survive without competing?
“It’s possible that when kin are grown together, they may balance their nutrient uptake and not be greedy,” Bais speculates.
The research also may have implications for the home gardener.
“Often we’ll put plants in the ground next to each other and when they don’t do well, we blame the local garden center where we bought them or we attribute their failure to a pathogen,” Bais says. “But maybe there’s more to it than that.”

34 comments
Comments feed for this article
October 26, 2009 at 5:04 am
lovewillbringustogether
3 Favourite Flowers?
Tricky – i love pretty much any flower for either it’s beauty or it’s uniqueness – or both. Do i pick the ones i think most unique? or the most beautiful? or the ones i think show most of both??
i guess one from each then?
Rose. and if i’m selecting one variety – then one i have, a ‘blue’ english tea rose.
Kangaroo Paw (Anigozanthos manglesii) Unique to Western Australia and our state floral emblem/flower. http://www.anbg.gov.au/emblems/wa.emblem.html
Orchids – the variety and rareity of some of these flowers is astounding. here in WA we have an orchid that actually flowers Underground – it can only be seen in flower when it is dug out of the soil!
The ’stems’ of multiple flowering ’slipper’ orchids i think are some of the most beautiful and decorative flowers – just awesome.
3 vegies? Tomato, (is that a veggie or a fruit?) Onion and Silverbeet (the green leafy stalky veg) and if a Tomato is a fruit then i’ll add Potato because i enjoy it cooked so many different ways but i’m sure all that starch and the fat i sometimes fry them in cannot be good for me?
3 vegies to ‘toss? Hmmm… Brussel sprouts – what IS it about those suckers?, Squash and i could quite happily never eat another piece of boiled cauliflower again.
I got a little lost with the biology prof’s findings (that name is really troubling me – Harsh Bais – is that for real??) was he saying that within a single species, plants will compete with each other unless they have a shared ‘parent’? or that all plants of a single species compete only with different plants but not with each other?
The former might help to answer something i have wondered about for some time now… i have noticed a few plants in my garden produce literally millions of seeds and yet not a single one ever grows close to where the plant drops the seeds.
i wonder if some plants are genetically designed so that they will only grow if their parent is not using the area for it’s own source of nutrients??
and what on earth is the point of putting all that energy into making so many seeds that never germinate?
i know that there are some plants whose seeds will only germinate if they have been first eaten and passed through a bird’s digestive system (and in so doing be moved away from the original plant) and here in WA some plants will not germinate seeds unless the parent plant is burned by a bushfire thus providing a need for a new plant to replace a potentially badly damaged or dying one?
Interesting to think about.
There may well be much more complexities to life than we yet understand.
Even if man often acts like he knows it all already.
<B
October 27, 2009 at 2:41 am
edfromct
Love, the I have seen some beautiful blue roses in a hot house, not sure if they were english tea rose.
A orchid that flowers underground? That is amazing. In Wikipedia I see it was found in Western Australia. It gives new meaning to “down under”. You Aussies do have very unique variety of plants and animals. Such as the Kangaroo Paw.
I read where the Kangaroo paw, as the state floral emblem, “is incorporated in the armorial bearings of Western Australia, granted by Royal Warrant on 17 March 1969.” Royal Warrant? The Brits have to approve your state emblems?
I’ll count the Tomato as a vegetable. Very versatile. Great in both salads and sauces. The same can be said for onions. I prefer the sweet Vidalia onions that grows in our state of Georgia, the home state, soon to be once again home, of our friend Mandy.
I had never heard of Silverbeet, but read is is another name for Chard, which is what your buddy David called it. Are you guys trying to confuse this poor old yank? Whatever you do call it, if any does give me some you can have it. However if you fry it, or anything else, in bacon fat I will probably like it.
We are in complete agreement on what to throw overboard. Brussel sprouts and boiled cauliflower, or any prepared any other way, will put me off a meal pretty quick. Squash is a game you play, not anything you would want to eat.
I’ll get back to you tomorrow on the findings in the article. It’s now 2:30 am here, and time for my beauty sleep. In my sleep is the only time anyone calls me beautiful.
October 30, 2009 at 2:42 am
lovewillbringustogether
Australia ia a Constitutional Monarchy with the Queen of Australia (who is also the Queen of England) as our titular head of state! She rarely visit but we have a Governor General who acts on her behalf here in this country – this is a post largely removed from our parliamentary government where we have almost total autonomy in everything but name.
The Royal warrant i think applies more to the right to have a ‘Coat of Arms’ by our state they are the official registrars of all Armoric heralds and devices in the British Empire – as it was
( We get to pick what we want on them – they ‘approve’ it, meaning it does not copy someone else’s previously registered)
Yep – on the West Coast here Silverbeet is the name we most commonly use for ‘Swiss’ Chard – full of iron and minerals for a healthy body and delicious if fried in bacon fat
i love that almost all onions when baked in an oven tend to have a unusually sweet flavour – ad a pat of butter and yumm-o!
i have a fancy also for sweet pickled onions ( usually half the size of a normal onion, pickled for a few weeks in a sweet spiced vinegar).
<B
October 30, 2009 at 9:19 pm
edfromct
There was an excellent documentary about agriculture on our Public Broadcasting Channel, The Botany of Desire. The show was based on a book of the same name by Ketzel Levine, written in 2001.
The basic premise was that man believes he is in control. When we feed, fertilize plants, and give them new homes, who is controlling who?
The PBS Documentary:
http://www.pbs.org/thebotanyofdesire/
Part 1 – Sweetness: The Taste of Apples. Explore the nature of sweetness and the science behind it.
Part 2 – Beauty: Patterns in Nature. Analyze our perceptions of beauty and its role in natural selection
Part 3 – Intoxication: In the Arms of Morpheus. Understand what happens when psychoactive plants alter the brain.
Part 4 – Control: Far Afield. Learn about biodiversity, genetic engineering, and the challenges of controlling nature.
Link to NPR interview with the author of the book the documentary was based on, Ketzel Levine.
http://www.npr.org/programs/talkingplants/radio/010604.pollan.html
November 2, 2009 at 4:25 am
lovewillbringustogether
That sounds like a show i’d find most interesting to watch Ed, i’ll look out for it.
Between Plants, cats and women – whyever would man think he has ANY control on or of this planet??
The human brain is not a very smart thing when viewed from certain angles.
<B
October 27, 2009 at 11:30 pm
edfromct
Harsh Bais is a real live person. At least the Delaware Biotechnology Institute site says he is.
http://www.dbi.udel.edu/People/Bais.html
I found an article from 2007 about Susan Dudley’s orignal study. From the article:
“Researchers at McMaster University have found that plants get fiercely competitive when forced to share their pot with strangers of the same species, but they’re accommodating when potted with their siblings.”
Full article:
http://dailynews.mcmaster.ca/story.cfm?id=4754
The next time you venture into your garden armed with plants, consider who you place next to whom. It turns out that the docile garden plant isn’t as passive as widely assumed, at least not with strangers.
Researchers at McMaster University have found that plants get fiercely competitive when forced to share their pot with strangers of the same species, but they’re accommodating when potted with their siblings.
The study appears today in the Royal Society journal Biology Letters.
“The ability to recognize and favour kin is common in animals, but this is the first time it has been shown in plants,” said Susan Dudley, associate professor of biology at McMaster University. “When plants share their pots, they get competitive and start growing more roots, which allows them to grab water and mineral nutrients before their neighbours get them. It appears, though, that they only do this when sharing a pot with unrelated plants; when they share a pot with family, they don’t increase their root growth. Because differences between groups of strangers and groups of siblings only occurred when they shared a pot, the root interactions may provide a cue for kin recognition.”
Though they lack cognition and memory, the study shows plants are capable of complex social behaviours such as altruism towards relatives, says Dudley. Like humans, the most interesting behaviours occur beneath the surface.
Dudley and her student, Amanda File, observed the behavior in sea rocket (Cakile edentula), a member of the mustard family native to beaches throughout North America, including the Great Lakes. So should gardeners arrange their plants like they would plan the seating at a dinner party?
“Gardeners have known for a long time that some pairs of species get along better than others, and scientists are starting to catch up with why that happens,” says Dudley. “What I’ve found is that plants from the same mother may be more compatible with each other than with plants of the same species that had different mothers. The more we know about plants, the more complex their interactions seem to be, so it may be as hard to predict the outcome as when you mix different people at a party.”
October 30, 2009 at 2:31 am
lovewillbringustogether
Thanks Ed – that clears my confusion up (well, on the siblings anyway
)
it sort of goes against my theory on the seeds however since this would suggest that seeds from a mother plant would do well growing close to ‘mom’? or is there a parent – sibling rivalry still i wonder?
i think i might have to place invite cards in my garden beds now?
<B
October 26, 2009 at 5:52 am
lovewillbringustogether
PS – why is that Tulip doing it’s best to look like a Double Carnation??
<B
October 27, 2009 at 11:34 pm
edfromct
I see some resemblance but the tips of the Sensual Touch Tulip look spiker(?).
http://media.photobucket.com/image/double%20carnation/scentedleaves/Carnation_flower_photo__14007.jpg
October 30, 2009 at 1:20 am
lovewillbringustogether
Those are excellent carnations, but like the Tulips there are several varieties and some have very similarly spikey like leaves to the tulip
i might be able to photo one from my garden soon?
<B
October 30, 2009 at 9:24 pm
edfromct
I have seen some pics on your site of your very well kept garden on your. I would like to see the result of your horticulture talents.
October 26, 2009 at 7:48 am
Indian Lake Papa
Favorite flowers? Easy for me.
1) Lilacs – what a variety of colors – we have several in our yard.
2) Roses – again, varieties are unlimited.
3) In florida I love the Amarillus’ when they bloom.
Veggies?
1) Potatoes
2) Corn on the cob – not in a can!
3) Gravy – thick gravy !! (Must be a veggie?)
Which ones (veggies) not to take?
1) Anything green and looks like a weed!
2) Anything orange and mushy.
3) Anything that ends in bean like Lima or kidney.
October 27, 2009 at 12:15 am
edfromct
Papa, roses seem to be every body’s favorite. Lilacs are very popular garden plants. I found a picture of a Jackpot Amarillus and they are a very pretty flower.
http://activerain.com/image_store/uploads/4/7/7/3/5/ar1241047753774.jpg
We agree on potatoes and corn. Corn on the cob, baked on a grill with the potatoes, is much better than the canned stuff. I don’t we can call gravy a vegetable, but I need a lot of it on most veggies for me to eat them.
Green and weed looking takes in a lot of vegetables,and carrots are orange, so I am going to guess you are not a big fan of most veggies. We agree on how bad Lima & kidney beans taste.
Does Mama have to keep reminding you to finish your veggies?
October 27, 2009 at 8:00 am
Indian Lake Papa
nope – actually I do quite well with my veggies. I eat more green veggies than I like to admit – Asparagus and spinach being two of my favorite.
October 26, 2009 at 10:02 am
David
Oh flowers…too hard to pick just three…but :
1. Dainty Bess Single Rose
2. Susannah Mary Camelia (named for my grandmother)
3.
I am a very big fan of veges, so picking 3 to keep is really hard. And broccoli is one of my absolutely faves, so…
1. Broccoli
2. Sweet Potato – the purple one, not the orange one really called kumera
3. potatoes
And 3 to toss…ummm…let’s just go with the most ordinary ones…
1. choko
2. squash
3. cassava
October 27, 2009 at 12:53 am
edfromct
Hi David.
The Dainty Bess Rose is very pretty. I could not find a picture of a Susannah Mary Camelia, but a had a cousin that grew some camelia and they are beautiful. I did find a picture of some lovely Cyclamen.
http://www.misterflorist.com/consumer/images/cyclamen.jpg
If we ever eat together, and they served broccoli, you could have all of mine. I have never had purple sweet potatoes. I looked up kumera, which is the Maori word for the plant. We are back in agreement with regular potatoes, my favorite variety is Yukon Gold, and Idaho for baking.
What you call cassava is sold in our markets as yucca, which looks like pieces of wood. I have never tried it.
Choko, listed in Wikipedia as Chayote is described as, “The flesh has a fairly bland taste, and a texture described as a cross between a potato and a cucumber.” That does not leave me wanting to try some any time soon.
October 28, 2009 at 6:24 pm
David
Yeah, choko…that’s a pretty accurate description…though I would change “fairly bland” to “utterly tasteless”
October 28, 2009 at 9:41 pm
edfromct
David sometimes the name does match how it taste.
October 26, 2009 at 10:02 am
David
Oops…3rd flower name should have been Cyclamen
October 26, 2009 at 7:57 pm
Debs
I don’t know why but this cracked me up… “Now we have evidence that plants recognize their siblings.” Like when the strawberries were worried because their parents were in a jam??? or why the watermelons decided to have a fancy wedding??? cause they canteloupe…
or how about the potatoe that became a detective cause he was good at keeping his eyes peeled…. hey you started it!
Ok, my three ark flowers would be…
1. Lilacs
2. Peonies
3. Roses
Pretty much anything fragrant to help with the animal odors…
My three veggies would be:
1. Butternut Squash
2. Corn on the Cob
3. Fresh peas
My three reject veggies would be:
1. Okra… (can hardly say it without bile forming)
2. Any hot peppers
3. Chard (blech)
October 27, 2009 at 12:57 am
edfromct
Deb, first I will get the bad vegatable jokes out of the way.
What do you get if you divide the circumference
of a pumpkin by its diameter?
Pumpkin pi.
What do you call a stolen yam?
A hot potato.
Everyone has these on their face?
Tulips
What does the letter “A” have in common with a flower?
They both have bees coming after them.
I love this Buddy Hackett line:
My mother’s menu consisted of two choices:
Take it or leave it.
October 27, 2009 at 1:10 am
edfromct
Lilacs, Roses and Peonies are all lovely followers. I liked this picture of a bouquet of Peonies:
http://www.parisfranceinc.com/portfolio/flowerbud/images/flowers/peonies.jpg
It looks like we all like our corn, especially on the cob. I guess if I had to pick a squash to eat it would be butternut. The only peas I like are snow pea they sever on mostly asian dishs.
I agree with you on Okra and Chard. I can enjoy some of the milder hot pepers in a sauce. My cousins son eats Habaneros straight from the market. That would kill my taste buds for a month.
October 26, 2009 at 10:37 pm
danielle
flowers:
tulips
hydrangeas
gerber daisies
veggies i take:
potatoes
macaroni and cheese (LOLOL…kidding!! if your answer to everything is bacon, why can’t i bring some comfort food along)
asparagus
green beans
veggies i dont take:
peppers
eggplant (maybe if you put bacon on it and bbq it…? lol)
some kind of bean
October 27, 2009 at 3:08 am
edfromct
Danielle, it would be great to visit the Tulip farms of Holland. Gerber daisies have such vibrant colors.
I had to lookup Hydrangeas. They are another very colorful flower and would be a great addition to any garden.
http://www.wholeblossoms.com/img/productos/Assorted-Hydrangeas-elite-w.jpg
I am with you on potatoes, but not the other two.
Even if we count mac & cheese as a veggie dish, you could have mine. It does seem to be the staple of most college students.
I know many people love asparagus tips. I am afraid I want nothing to do with any part of the plant.
The only way I enjoy beans is when there are baked Boston style, in bacon fat of course.
I don’t much care for raw peppers. I do enjoy some recipes with mildly hot pepper sauce in them.
Why in the world is something as bland tasting as eggplant have the glorious tasting egg in it’s name. If you put a good sauce on it I can enjoy it, but if you put a good sauce on anything it can taste good.
“Some kind of Bean”. Mr. Bean? Orson Bean, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orson_Bean?
My favorite show as a child was “Beany & Cecil (the Seasick Sea Serpent)”, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beany_and_Cecil
October 27, 2009 at 9:54 pm
danielle
yes, mr. bean will not be allowed on the ark.
October 27, 2009 at 10:37 am
Michelle
ONLY THREE FLOWERS!!!
Hmph!
1. Lillies — day lillies, lilly of the valley, tiger lillies, water lillies…all kinds of lillies…but my all-time favorite: Peruvian Lillies. Petite, perfect, colorful and long-lasting.
2. Gladiolas — again, so many varieties!!
3. Sunflowers — and I don’t just mean the big huge ones with the great tasting seeds…those are wonderful, but there are many others with red and orange and even violet. Sunflowers make me smile.
Three veggies (again, terribly hard…I LOVE my veggies):
1. Tomatoes
2. Potatoes
3. Spinach
Three to throw out!?!??!?! I have no idea…hmmm…I’ve never met a veggie I didn’t like…sorry. Just can’t do that one.
October 27, 2009 at 3:40 pm
edfromct
Michelle, there is only so much room on any boat. If you want you can leave some of your animals off, and take more flowers and veggies.
I had never seen Peruvian Lillies. They are very colorful flowers.
http://www.bloomsofguernsey.com/Portals/0/alstroemeria/bigstockphoto_Alstroemeria_Flowers_1252364-(2).jpg
Gladiolas are another plant that comes in many different colors. All beautiful.
I had not realized Sunflowers came so in different colors. The only ones I have seen are the big yellow ones. Having Sunflowers in your garden will ensure you will have many squirrel and bird visitors.
Tomatoes can be used in many different ways. Eaten raw in salads, or to make many delicious sauces.
Almost every picked Potatoes. There would no shortage of these versatile vegetables in the post flood world.
Spinach I can only eat one way, in a salad. Spinach salad is one of my favorites, with egg and bacon in it what is not to love.
Michelle you can have all of my veggies if I can have all our meat.
If you recall from a prior post even some spiders have gone vegetarian.
October 28, 2009 at 8:39 pm
Michelle
The Peruvian lillies last forever in a bouquet! I love picking them up at the grocery store and then have fresh flowers for two weeks. Gladiolas are good for long lasting certerpieces too.
Haha!! I will gladly give you all my meat for all your veggies. Especially the lima and kidney beans (although technically, are beans vegetables or legumes…???). I could easily be a vegetarian if someone will do the cooking.
I agree. With bacon and egg spinach is wonderful! Then put some spicey shrimp on top…ooooooooo!!!
October 27, 2009 at 12:46 pm
gchyayles
Flowers:
1. Daisies
2. Lavender roses (yes they have to be lavender)
3. Lily of the valley (apparently that’s my birth flower)
Vegetables:
1. Potatoes
2. Broccoli
3. Carrots
Not-so-much
1. Brussel sprouts
2. Egg Plant
3. Turnips
October 27, 2009 at 4:08 pm
edfromct
Gchyayles, I just read that Daisies, Roses and Lilies are the three most popular flowers in the US.
You have something in common with my mother, the Lily of the Valley was her birth plant as well, also her nickname, Lily.
Lavender is a beautiful color, and scent.
http://cdn2.overstock.com/images/products/3/P10273545.jpg
Another Potato lover. They are very easy to grow, as my Irish ancestors found out. Even my Latvian step-mother said she could live on Potatoes alone.
You can have all the Broccoli, if anyone makes the mistake of serving it to me. One of my favorite Chinese dishes is General Tso’s Chicken, which most restaurants here serve with Broccoli. Needless to say there is a pile of Broccoli left over when I am finished.
We are back on the same side with Carrots. I love glazed carrots, and often have them. I still need glasses to see, so Carrots did help me in that regard.
Brussel sprouts are one of my least favorite food. Egg Plant to me has no taste on it’s own, so why bother with it. I had forgot how bad Turnips taste.
We agree on all the veggie choices except Broccoli. If I ever eat at your house just remember to make it double portions for you, and none for me.
October 28, 2009 at 12:48 am
gchyayles
So your Mom was born in May? How kewel!
Lavender is actually my favorite color. I like purple in general but lavender is my all time favorite color.
Funny how they are the three most popular flowers in America and I’m not even American LOL
Awwww you don’t like broccoli
And I like it best cooked in Chinese dishes (garlic chicken yummy)! You can ask them to exclude the broccoli you know just like I always ask them to add extra baby corn (loveeee baby corn!).
Egg plant and turnips are huge vegetables in Pakistani dishes. BLUKH. Disliked the taste growing up and still do.
Thanks again for fun posts!
October 28, 2009 at 1:50 am
edfromct
What is even keweler is that I share your birth flower as well, born May 21st, just a few years before you.
I looked up some Pakistani receipes I found Handi Kabab (stuff minced meat, mutton or beef, kabob) that looks interesting.
http://www.angelfire.com/country/fauziaspakistan/handikabab.html
October 28, 2009 at 3:30 pm
gchyayles
Ohhhhh ten days before my birthday! I’m May 31st
Yeah Haandi is good whether you use chicken, beef, or lamb.
I miss home food
October 28, 2009 at 9:37 pm
edfromct
Just think how much fun you will have introducing you child to Pakistani cooking. You do cook don’t you.